CHAPTER III
EXPERIMENTAL METHOD
X-ray diffraction data were acquired using copper Kα radiation, a graphite diffracted beam monochromator, and scintillation detector on a Bragg-Brentano
focusing diffractometer. The x-ray source was a conventional sealed 2500 watt x-ray tube operated at 50kV and 40 mA. Incident and diffracted beam slits were 1.0 and
0.2 deg., respectively, chosen for high intensity. Data
were collected by step counting at 0.02 deg. intervals for
2 seconds per data point.
3.1 Experimental Determination of Reference Intensity
Ratios
RIR values were determined using commercially available
pure samples of HA, β-TCP and CaO.
Pure α-TCP could not be obtained, and only a mixture
containing a small fraction of β-TCP was available. The RIR value for α-TCP was obtained from the mixture of α- and β-TCP after
quantification of the amount of β-TCP in the
mixture. Alpha-quartz, rather than α-Al2O3,
was selected initially as a suitable internal standard because peak
interference was minimal and finely ground (5 μm) pure powder is readily available as a stable reference standard. Mixtures
were prepared for measurement of the intensity ratios needed for the
calculation of RIR values for each phase. At least five runs were
made for each phase with the powder samples remixed and repacked in the sample
holders between each run to reduce errors due to inhomogeneity of the powder
mixtures. The mean and standard deviation for RIR values
calculated for each phase are presented in Table 1.
![]() |
The RIR values of a commercial sintered
HA plasma spray starting powder and a laboratory precipitate preparation were
found to differ by approximately 6%. Both samples were free of any contaminants
detectable by x-ray diffraction and were obtained as “pure” HA powders. Minor
variation or substitution in the apatite structure is assumed to alter the
structure factor and the RIR values measured for the two samples.
It is generally recommended that RIR values be determined experimentally
for any phase using the data reduction methods and instruments to be employed
for
measurement. [21]
3.2 Data Reduction Strategy
Known mixtures of HA, α-TCP, β-TCP, and CaO were prepared to develop a data
collection and reduction strategy in which the angular regions of peak
integration
and background were selected. The known mixtures were also used to test the
validity of the RIR values and relative intensities. A typical
diffraction pattern for a mixture containing 85% HA and additional contaminant
phases, as indicated, is shown in Figure 2. ![]() |
Plasma-sprayed HA coatings can vary widely in the amount of the glassy Ca/P phase producing the broad amorphous peak near 30 deg. The broad, diffuse peak from the glassy phase was approximated by fitting a Pearson VII function profile over a range sufficient to define the contribution of the broad tails. Much narrower Pearson VII functions were used to define the contribution of the neighboring HA peaks to the combined diffraction pattern. Peak profile fitting of the height, position, width and the power term independently for each peak was performed using the method of Gupta and Cullity [26] assuming a Kα doublet. The deconvolution of the overlapping peaks is shown in Figure 3.
After examination of the diffraction patterns of both
the known mixtures and actual coating samples, regions of true background, beyond
the tails of the broad glassy Ca/P peak, were selected which would be suitable
for analysis of any likely concentrations of the phases encountered in plasma
sprayed HA coatings. The following data reduction strategy was developed for
acquiring the integrated intensities necessary to quantify mixtures of α-TCP, β-TCP, CaO, and
HA. (Provision is made for interference effects from β-Ca2P2O7, but this phase has not been observed in
plasma-sprayed coatings in this laboratory, and RIR values have
yet to be determined.)
1. The α-TCP content is obtained by integrating the α-TCP (331), (132), and (151) peaks from 23.8 to 24.8
degrees. This region is free from interference from any other phase likely to
be found in HA samples. A quadratic background is assumed.
2. The (008),
(210), and (211) β-Ca2P2O7 peaks
are integrated from 29.3 to 30.20 degrees to allow calculation of the intensity
of the 100% peak. No pure sample of this phase has been available to allow the
development of RIR values for quantification, but the integrated
intensities may be corrected for interference. The integrated intensity will be
in error due to interference from the β-TCP (300) and
the α-TCP (113) peaks. This region is integrated assuming a
linear background and a Pearson VII functional form of the peaks
3. surrounding
the region, including the diffuse peak 30.5 degrees to 31.5 degrees. The region
in corrected for α-TCP (170) and
(511) peak interference, and possible β-Ca2P2O7 (204)
and (212) interference, if present. The β-TCP peak being
used for quantification is the (0210) peak. This region is integrated in the
same fashion as the β-Ca2P2O7 peaks
above.
4. The calcium oxide
content is determined by integration from 37.0 degrees to 38.5 degrees with correction
for the β-TCP (1211) and (315) peaks. This region contains the
100% (200) calcium oxide peak and is integrated assuming a quadratic form to the
background.
5. Finally, the
entire region from 38.5 degrees to 59.0 degrees is integrated assuming a linear
background and corrected for interference by α-TCP, β-TCP, calcium oxide, and possibly β-Ca2P2O7 to obtain the HA content. Many peaks are
included in the integration range to reduce the effects of preferred orientation.
3.3 Relative Intensities
The relative intensities of the peaks or peak regions used
in the analysis were obtained by direct measurement of samples of each phase.
The integrated intensities were calculated from Pearson VII function peak
profiles fitted by regression after background subtraction. Table 2 summarizes
the combined fractional relative intensities for each phase summing all of the
peaks found within the integration ranges shown. The HA values are the averages
of results from pure samples obtained from five different sources.
![]() |
3.4 Plasma-sprayed coatings
HA plasma-sprayed coating samples reportedly obtained
from a variety of commercial sources and representing a wide range of both
dental and prosthetic applications, as well as experimental coatings. The set of
coating samples was provided by a client for x-ray diffraction characterization
and demonstration of the proposed method of quantitative phase analysis. The
origin of the individual samples was not provided to insure
a blind evaluation. The results are reported here to show application of the
method to a variety of commercial coatings and to demonstrate performance on a
wide range of compositions. All the HA coating samples were analyzed nondestructively,
mounting the coated substrates in a flat sample holder. A 1.0 deg. incident
beam was used in a constant incident angle mode, allowing the width of the
irradiated area to decrease with increasing diffraction angle. Using Cu Kα radiation and a graphite monochromator, as detailed
above, the irradiated area ranged from nominally 10 x 12 mm at the lowest diffraction
angle of 20 deg. to 10 x 5 mm at the highest angle of 60 deg. A quartz external
standard was measured concurrently using the same experimental conditions.
The results for the plasma sprayed coating samples are
presented in Table 4 and graphically in Figure 4. The crystallinity, taken as
the sum of the crystalline fractions of the samples, varied from 38% to 84%.
The most common secondary phase was β-TCP, which
was observed in all of the coating samples, ranging from nominally 2% to 6%. Up
to 2% α-TCP was attributed to four of the samples, but as
noted above, the combination of the two TCP components is more reliable. No
significant amount of CaO was observed in any of the coatings.
![]() |
The error calculated for the determination of the
major HA fraction in the coatings is higher (ranging from 2% to 6% for the
individual samples) than that reported for the known mixtures (0.6% and 1.6%)
in Table 3.
![]() |
Diffraction from the glassy Ca/P phase, which exceeded 60% of the material in some of the coatings, must be subtracted form the contribution of the other phases introducing error in the determination of the net integrated intensities of all of the phases. The glassy phase does not occur in the fully crystalline known mixtures. The fraction of HA is calculated by subtracting the contributions from all of the other phases from the extended integration range, compounding the error in measurement.
A deficiency of the data reduction scheme currently employed
is the sensitivity to the contribution of the secondary maximum of the
amorphous glassy material to the long integration range (38.5 to 59.0 deg.)
used to quantify the HA component. Integration of the full diffraction pattern
obtained from the amorphous material produced by plasma spray deposition
(Figure
1.g) reveals that the secondary maximum is on the
order of 12% of the intensity of the primary, using the integration ranges
proposed. For a typical HA plasma sprayed coating with a crystalline HA content
on the order of 70%, the error due to the secondary maximum would be on the
order of 4% of the HA content reported, less than the nominal random error for measurement
of coatings. Because the intensity of the primary maximum is measured in the
analysis, the method could be improved and applicability extended to coatings
of lower crystallinity by correcting for the interference from the secondary
amorphous maximum.





No comments:
Post a Comment